Bathtub or Shower? How to Choose What’s Best for Your Bathroom Remodel

One of the most common decisions in a bathroom remodel is choosing between a bathtub and a shower. Each has its advantages, and the right pick depends on how you use your bathroom, who uses it, and how much space you have to work with.

Here’s a look at how to approach this decision with confidence and what to keep in mind before making the call.

Before comparing features, take a step back and think about your bathroom’s size and how it fits into your day-to-day life. Ask yourself:

Is space tight? Showers typically take up less room, which makes them a go-to for smaller bathrooms.

Who uses the bathroom most? Families with young kids often lean toward tubs for easier bath time. Showers, especially low-threshold or walk-in models, are more accessible for people with limited mobility.

What’s your routine like? If speed matters in the morning, a shower may be more practical. If you look forward to long soaks at the end of the day, a tub will likely feel more satisfying.

Bathtubs turn your bathroom into a space for relaxation. Here are a few reasons to include one in your remodel:

A Place to Unwind
A warm bath at the end of the day can help ease stress and promote relaxation. If you enjoy carving out time to slow down, a bathtub supports that lifestyle.

Kid-Friendly Convenience
Bathtubs make it easier to bathe small children and are often preferred by families with toddlers.

Style Versatility
From modern soaking tubs to classic clawfoot designs, bathtubs offer a wide range of looks to match your aesthetic.

Resale Value
Having at least one bathtub in the home is often seen as a plus for potential buyers, especially those with families.

If you want something efficient and modern, a shower might be a better fit. Here’s why:

Quick and Efficient
Showers are ideal for fast-paced mornings and refreshing after a workout.

Saves Space
A corner or walk-in shower can make the most of a compact layout.

Mobility-Friendly
Showers can be customized with safety features like grab bars, benches, and curbless entryways, making them easier for older adults or those with physical limitations.

Lower Water Use
With the right showerhead, you can keep water use in check while still enjoying strong water pressure.

• Showers don’t offer the same soak-and-relax experience that tubs do.
• Bathing small children or pets can be trickier in a shower-only space.

If you need the benefits of both, a combination setup is a smart compromise. These are especially useful in homes where bathrooms serve multiple functions.

Once you’ve chosen a direction, consider these finishing touches:

Materials
Common materials include fiberglass, acrylic, porcelain, and stone. Each offers different benefits in terms of durability and upkeep.

Fixtures
For showers, consider features like handheld sprayers, multiple heads, or rainfall effects. For tubs, think about the placement of the faucet: wall-mounted, deck-mounted, or freestanding.

Enclosures
Frameless glass gives a sleek look. Frosted or textured options offer more privacy. Tubs can use glass sliders or classic curtains.

In the end, your bathroom should reflect how you live. A shower might be the right call if you want efficiency, space-saving design, and easy maintenance. A bathtub might suit you better if relaxation and family functionality are priorities. If you want it all, a combination unit lets you cover your bases.

Sands and Sons Bathroom Remodeling can help you weigh your options and bring your vision to life. Contact us to schedule a no-obligation consultation with one of our expert bathroom designers. Call 623-363-2284 today to schedule!